Jump to content
  • Announcements

    • I.Srodka

      Nowa Struktura Forum   01/04/18

      Szanowni Użytkownicy Forum!   Jak zapewne widzicie, na forum zaszła pewna reorganizacja, która będzie w dalszym ciągu postępować.   Od dzisiaj dział Moduły / Produkty został podzielony na podkategorie, więc od teraz proszę o zakładanie tematów w odpowiednich działach.   Poprzednie tematy będą stopniowo przenoszone do odpowiednich kategorii.    Pozdrawiamy, Zespół FIBARO
    • I.Srodka

      New Forum Structure   01/04/18

      Dear Forum Users!   As you can see, some changes in Forum structure has been made and we are going to reorganize even further.   From now on, Modules / Products has been divided into subcategories (particular devices), so please create new topics in the corresponding subcategories.   We will address previously created topics in Modules and we will be moving them on a daily basis.   Kind regards, FIBARO Team
    • T.Konopka

      DOWNLOADS - new way of sharing solutions!   01/17/18

      Dear users, We want you to have a great time here on the Forum, therefore, we are introducing a new tool for sharing solutions! DOWNLOADS - a system of file sharing for all of you. DOWNLOADS - support topics - this is a new category for support topics. Check the short guide for Downloads on how to add a solution (all files have to be approved).   Crowd's Solutions will be closed for new submissions, but still open for replies in remaining topics. We ask the authors of the solutions to add their solutions to Downloads with the link to the topic at the top of the description. We will merge the support topic with the one from Crowd's Solutions.   If you have any questions, feel free to ask our administrators - @T.Konopka and @I.Srodka!
    • T.Konopka

      DOWNLOADS - nowy sposób dzielenia się rozwiązaniami!   01/17/18

      Szanowni użytkownicy, Chcemy, abyście świetnie spędzali czas na Forum, dlatego przedstawiamy wam nowe narzędzie do dzielenia się rozwiązaniami! DOWNLOADS - system dodawania i pobierania plików. DOWNLOADS - support topics - to jest nowa kategoria z tematami wsparcia. Sprawdźcie przewodnik dla Downloads, aby wiedzieć jak dodać rozwiązanie (wszystkie pliki muszą zostać zatwierdzone).   Rozwiązania Społeczności zostaną zamknięte dla nowych tematów, jednak tematy już wczęśniej dodane będą nadal dostępne. Prosimy autorów rozwiązań do przenoszenia ich do Downloads - prosimy o dodanie linkiem do tematu na górze opisu. Połączymy wtedy temat wsparcia z tematem z Rozwiązań Społeczności.   W przypadku pytań, prosimy o kontaktowanie się z administratorami - @T.Konopka and @I.Srodka. (Rozwiązania mogą być dodawane w języku polskim!)

Question

Guys,

 

I have seen some very cheap Z-wave devices at eBay...

Please see link below 

Please login or register to see this link.

 

Ia anyone has tried these no brand devices?

It looks like "original" copy of some famous smart home manufacturers .

Would like to hear your opinion on that..... thanks

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

124 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0

Okay guys, the plug just stopped communicate over z-wave network after five days of use. It can be turned on and off, but only with button. I tried do re-add it if that would solve that communication problem, but i cannot connect the plug with Fibaro anymore - obviosly z-wave chip was somehow damaged. 

 

Note: After i plug it in, LED flashes five times with violet color 

Edited by play3man

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0

If you can afford an hc2 or HC light, why go cheap on actors and switches?! Smartthings is half the price and then you could have boughten a ton of switches, actors, etc with the extra money you saved on buying a much cheaper controller...  Really defeats the whole purpose of purchasing a Fibaro controller in the beginning.....

Edited by matt1981
edit

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0

Interesting, topic, we pay probably the highest (I'm assuming) globally for all the zwave components here in AU/NZ , it's ridiculous how expensive things are when you only have a small population, so we don't even get these smaller manufacturers understandably changing frequency for our market size.

But even if we did have these cheaper alternatives, I'd still be dubious. I can't tell you the number of Chinese 'things' I've purchased thinking it was a bargain and ended up throwing away, ( then having to either spend the other 50% saved, or just get the name branded one anyway ) the only issue I've had with a Fibaro branded component was resolved and replaced. Still some people use lesser known brands and some use overpriced name brands .. the thing I always think about though, is .. if a widget has say a bit of plastic, a certain number of chips and some metal in it .. and another widget has to have basically the same in it to function .. then how can one be 2 or 3 or more times the price ?

As I'm in marketing and sales for a small engineering firm, I can tell you my opinion .. someone is either meeting all the required certification criteria, &/or making more margin, and someone is cutting corners if basically "like for like" items are significantly disparately priced. .. 

 

In this case, because I like to sleep soundly at night, and these are things that I rely upon stuck in my roof space or wall, to keep me secure, and safe .. I'd personally pass .. we aren't talking sneakers or t-shirts here !

Then you have OTA updates, which can fix any niggling issues, or improve functionality etc .. I mean I get it ($) , but .. I wouldn't get it :) 

 

The upside for people like me though, is if more people buy the lesser known brands, market pressure will reduce the pricing of the named brands assuming margin is the root of the pricing difference !

 

Just my 2¢ worth.

Cheers,

al.

 

 

 

Edited by alandee
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
  • Inquirer
  • Guys,

     

    at Gear Best now almost half a price from eBay - Neo coolcam smart, light switches and door sensor

    Please login or register to see this link.

     

    Share this post


    Link to post
    Share on other sites

    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

    ×