Jump to content
  • Announcements

    • I.Srodka

      Nowa Struktura Forum   01/04/18

      Szanowni Użytkownicy Forum!   Jak zapewne widzicie, na forum zaszła pewna reorganizacja, która będzie w dalszym ciągu postępować.   Od dzisiaj dział Moduły / Produkty został podzielony na podkategorie, więc od teraz proszę o zakładanie tematów w odpowiednich działach.   Poprzednie tematy będą stopniowo przenoszone do odpowiednich kategorii.    Pozdrawiamy, Zespół FIBARO
    • I.Srodka

      New Forum Structure   01/04/18

      Dear Forum Users!   As you can see, some changes in Forum structure has been made and we are going to reorganize even further.   From now on, Modules / Products has been divided into subcategories (particular devices), so please create new topics in the corresponding subcategories.   We will address previously created topics in Modules and we will be moving them on a daily basis.   Kind regards, FIBARO Team
    • T.Konopka

      DOWNLOADS - new way of sharing solutions!   01/17/18

      Dear users, We want you to have a great time here on the Forum, therefore, we are introducing a new tool for sharing solutions! DOWNLOADS - a system of file sharing for all of you. DOWNLOADS - support topics - this is a new category for support topics. Check the short guide for Downloads on how to add a solution (all files have to be approved).   Crowd's Solutions will be closed for new submissions, but still open for replies in remaining topics. We ask the authors of the solutions to add their solutions to Downloads with the link to the topic at the top of the description. We will merge the support topic with the one from Crowd's Solutions.   If you have any questions, feel free to ask our administrators - @T.Konopka and @I.Srodka!
    • T.Konopka

      DOWNLOADS - nowy sposób dzielenia się rozwiązaniami!   01/17/18

      Szanowni użytkownicy, Chcemy, abyście świetnie spędzali czas na Forum, dlatego przedstawiamy wam nowe narzędzie do dzielenia się rozwiązaniami! DOWNLOADS - system dodawania i pobierania plików. DOWNLOADS - support topics - to jest nowa kategoria z tematami wsparcia. Sprawdźcie przewodnik dla Downloads, aby wiedzieć jak dodać rozwiązanie (wszystkie pliki muszą zostać zatwierdzone).   Rozwiązania Społeczności zostaną zamknięte dla nowych tematów, jednak tematy już wczęśniej dodane będą nadal dostępne. Prosimy autorów rozwiązań do przenoszenia ich do Downloads - prosimy o dodanie linkiem do tematu na górze opisu. Połączymy wtedy temat wsparcia z tematem z Rozwiązań Społeczności.   W przypadku pytań, prosimy o kontaktowanie się z administratorami - @T.Konopka and @I.Srodka. (Rozwiązania mogą być dodawane w języku polskim!)
Sign in to follow this  

Pet peeves with the Home center 2 (and HCL most likely)

Recommended Posts

Dear Fibaro,


After having used the system for a couple of years now, I would like to share my primary annoyances with the system:


I got the feeling that the creative people that built the original functionality must have been fired as some point along the way. 


* the panel for energy consumption is really great, and the built in functionality to add a default power consumption for on/off switches that without power metering is as far as I can tell kind of unique among controllers.

  And the same goes for temperature measurements.No other system that I am aware of allows for an as flexible adjustment of sensor readings before they are stored overall. And the summaries are nice.

 But, what about humidity? Is this not what kills buildings ? Not worth having the same control over? 
 What about CO2-levels? Radon metering is coming now too, and makes huge sense? Naively you would be able to have just a simple copy of the temperature panel show up for humidity measurements, but maybe I am too optimistic.


* The heating panel is ok and I love the ability to easily set Holiday and adjust the schedule manually for a few hours directly from the Apps (phone and tablet)

  BUT - how come there is not overall "Away", "Home" and "On vacation" modes for the whole system set up by Fibaro? First of all, I think that the term "Holiday" that you chose for the heating panel is not optimal. I am not a native speaker, but there are "Bank holidays" too, and this does not mean that there are less people in the house, most likely more people actually. So, "On vacation" or "On Holiday" is perhaps better?? Or, something. 

  Anyway, the problem is that there is no way to interact with the heating schedule system in a sensible way, so the users are doing the job that should have been done by Fibaro developers and setting up a consensus on how house state should be stored in variables. The heating schedule mode and the user developed house mode do not interact, so in the end you have just a silly situation.

This is not creative and forward thinking, it is just dumb.


* The Lua library was probably never intended for home automation, IMHO. I have stated this before, but I think it needs repeating. A serious library for Home Automation would have an robust way of setting up timers and a structure for setting up delayed events (with restarts if triggered again) and stuff like that, which you will always need at some point. 


*  Why there are two different ways of making HTTP calls in scenes and in VD:s, I don't know. Really silly.


* Why are we not allowed to have a look at the network structure built up by the controller? It would, I think, potentially save users a lot of frustration if you could just have a look at how things are set up in the end. 



  • Thanks 1

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this