Switch button face not changing on click

[Neo Andersson 230]

Hello

Anyone know about this bug?

Using the new switch type button in a quickapp never changes its face when clicked. Neither in web interface nor in Yubii.

It only changes when in EDIT mode of quickapp.

 

And if somone can share with me, how to udpdate its state from LUA, becuase

Please login or register to see this code.

doesnt work

Edited November 25, 2023 by Neo Andersson

[Joep 200]

I'm a little bit late to the party, but you have to send the boolean as a string, and then it works:

 

Please login or register to see this code.

 

[Joep 200]

Please login or register to see this link.

I explain with real world examples how the new switch button can be programmed with Lua. 😀

[Neo Andersson 230]

this switch button doesnt work as intended. It never changes its state. @m.roszak Michael, maybe you can assist on this a little bit. See on the video, i am pressing the switch but it doesn't state its value. Always sending true in param.values[1].

[jgab 2,641]

It works for me (MacOS/Safari) if I do

Please login or register to see this code.

[Neo Andersson 230]

23 minutes ago, jgab said:

It works for me (MacOS/Safari) if I do

Please login or register to see this code.

yes, we can set buttonface direclty by updateView, but first of all i think this is a faulty behaviour..why would we need to set it manually? it should change according to its state, but the problem is, its state never changes as you can see, It is always true.

[jgab 2,641]

Yes, it's buggy that we need to call updateview but it does change state if we do it.

Please login or register to see this code.

 

[jgab 2,641]

I did post a generic patch +2months ago that fixes this for switches, sliders and drop down menus 

Please login or register to see this code.

 

[w.rys 7]

The switch control operates similarly to the slider. Its purpose is to grant you full control, allowing you to decide when the view should update.

Typically, when a user interacts with a slider/switch value, data is sent to a third-party device. However, there's a possibility of communication errors occurring. In such cases, the slider/switch should remain in its previous position until confirmation is received.
The view should only update after receiving an acknowledgment (ACK) or a report from the device indicating that it has achieved the desired state.

 

However, it might be worth considering enabling an optimistic approach, where the view state changes immediately after the user's action. We'll explore this further

Attached is an example featuring a switch, with the added bonus of handling long presses.

Please login or register to see this attachment.

[Neo Andersson 230]

42 minutes ago, w.rys said:

The switch control operates similarly to the slider. Its purpose is to grant you full control, allowing you to decide when the view should update.

Typically, when a user interacts with a slider/switch value, data is sent to a third-party device. However, there's a possibility of communication errors occurring. In such cases, the slider/switch should remain in its previous position until confirmation is received.
The view should only update after receiving an acknowledgment (ACK) or a report from the device indicating that it has achieved the desired state.

 

However, it might be worth considering enabling an optimistic approach, where the view state changes immediately after the user's action. We'll explore this further

Attached is an example featuring a switch, with the added bonus of handling long presses.

Please login or register to see this attachment.

It is not only about the face problem. It is buggy in general. It never changes its state. Not only its buttonface, but in onToggles callback function you never get the real state of the switch. It is a faulty behaviour. It always sends TRUE..

[Joep 200]

For me it works, I tested it last weekend. Strange it always sends true at your side.