Native support of ZigBee ?

[olafkatzer 5]

Hello,

ist ZigBee native supported by HC3.

I want to controll Hue Lights without Hue Bridge.

 

thanks

[VedranS 24]

I want performance which i paid for, ita not about being easy or hard. Fibaro simply dont have enough users or developers. And they are making it worse with *abuse* they put out. Anyway i am done with fibaro. Maybe i find another sucker to sell hc3

[PrivatHome 5]

52 minutes ago, VedranS said:

If they dont make changes in development they will be overrun soon. 

That is absolutely right ! Will disconnect my HC3! Maybe contact FIBARO again directly ...

[PrivatHome 5]

36 minutes ago, rangee said:

yes. fibaro gateway is not easy.

If you want 100% performance, 

you should be developer or request to installer.

Anyway, smartthings is easy, but it can not perform powerful automation. 

I don't need a "powerful device", expensive device if it doesn't work as advertised.

HC3 = NO 100% performance for me! A small private user ... Apparently not intended for simple small users ...

[SmartHomeEddy 1,005]

3 hours ago, VedranS said:

Maybe i find another sucker to sell hc3

if you are convinced the HC3 is rubbish, and you try to sell rubbish to “another sucker”, they can file a lawsuit against you. There are people on this forum who know how that works ?. And someone selling something that is rubbish is a jerk. 

[VedranS 24]

Yeah i am conviced hc3 is rubbish, and only one who needs to be sued is fibaro. and i meant to abnother sucker like me who bought that *abuse* in a first place.  Clearly i am not only one who thinks that way, you and maybe 2, 3 other people on this forum doesn agree with problem fubaro has. Maybe you are milking money from it. I dont see any logical reason to defend fibaro for being *abuse* firm.

[VedranS 24]

Its not worth arguing any more, at least not for me, new users will see that its a mistake to spend money on this system. I dont know how many users fibaro has, maybe 4000? And on this forum maybe 5 people who knows and have a will do develop something? Marketplace is empty for a year. It has 2,3 good quick app.  That is not acceptible for many users, not just me. 

[SmartHomeEddy 1,005]

1 minute ago, VedranS said:

That is not acceptible for many users, not just me. 

then why are you here ?

[VedranS 24]

I got notification on mail, someone tagged me. Thats why i come back on this forum. 

[10der 832]

On 12/4/2020 at 8:14 PM, SmartHomeEddy said:

If you like the Schwaiger Home Gateway, get rid of the Fibaro gateway and use the Schwaiger. 

Sir, if I like a big b( .)(. )bs like Samantha Fox, is still I need to change my wife, with which I have been for over 30 years?

[SmartHomeEddy 1,005]

8 minutes ago, 10der said:

Sir, if I like a big b( .)(. )bs like Samantha Fox, is still I need to change my wife, with which I have been for over 30 years?

 

Yes, or stop complaining about your sweet wife with small b( .)(. )bs ?

[PrivatHome 5]

19 hours ago, VedranS said:

Its not worth arguing any more, at least not for me, new users will see that its a mistake to spend money on this system. I dont know how many users fibaro has, maybe 4000? And on this forum maybe 5 people who knows and have a will do develop something? Marketplace is empty for a year. It has 2,3 good quick app.  That is not acceptible for many users, not just me. 

I have to absolutely agree with you and it is no longer worth arguing here! I'll take a different path.

19 hours ago, SmartHomeEddy said:

then why are you here ?

Oh my goodness Vedran S and private users where are we here ??

On 12/4/2020 at 7:14 PM, SmartHomeEddy said:

If you like the Schwaiger Home Gateway, get rid of the Fibaro gateway and use the Schwaiger. 

That's exactly what I'm going to do. I already mentioned that! Are you interested in buying the Gateway HC3? Or do you know someone who would like to buy this?

 

[PrivatHome 5]

On 5/3/2020 at 6:56 PM, olafkatzer said:

Hello,

ist ZigBee native supported by HC3.

I want to controll Hue Lights without Hue Bridge.

 

thanks

According to the description, yes but ... I don't know Philips Hue ... maybe about LUA ... BUA or HUE A ... Joking aside, I don't know ... Does anyone from the HC3 experts here know?

 

Laut Beschreibung ja aber.... Philips Hue weiß ich nicht ... vielleicht über LUA... BUA oder HUE A... Spaß beiseite weiss ich nicht...Weiss das jemand von den HC3 Experten hier?

Edited December 9, 2020 by PrivatHome
additional question

[PrivatHome 5]

On 12/8/2020 at 11:48 PM, VedranS said:

Its not worth arguing any more, at least not for me, new users will see that its a mistake to spend money on this system. I dont know how many users fibaro has, maybe 4000? And on this forum maybe 5 people who knows and have a will do develop something? Marketplace is empty for a year. It has 2,3 good quick app.  That is not acceptible for many users, not just me. 

VedraS, I am absolutely agree with you!  

Will not look any further in this forum. At first I thought I was in a forum where Fibaro himself is involved with admin support. However, this is not the case and by experts I understand something else! It is a problem from the Fibaro company. I have to see if I can get ahead directly through the CEO ... Otherwise I will disconnect the HC3 now. Maybe I'll try to offer the Power Gate to see what's on offer ...

[Stef4321 4]

I asked and this is the response

 

Due to COVID-19 Zigbee implementation had to be postponed - my sincerest apologies for that, however we were not provided any dates

[kevin 34]

19 hours ago, Stef4321 said:

I asked and this is the response

 

Due to COVID-19 Zigbee implementation had to be postponed - my sincerest apologies for that, however we were not provided any dates

 

I got a different answer about Zigbee ?

 

"Due to the higher priority of improving communication with Nice radios, the implementation of Zigbee has been postponed. It's not likely to be available any time soon, I'm very sorry."
 

Apparently there is also confusion at Fibaro?. But seeing there response it will take a while before we can use Zigbee on a HC3

[10der 832]

unfortunately for example i am selling my Z-Wave devices and replace by ZigBee. 

one never knows and with last device with Z-wave will be sell HC3 also.

 

my current ZigBee network is 20 devices vs 100 (now 65) works perfectly!

[akatar 208]

42 minutes ago, 10der said:

unfortunately for example i am selling my Z-Wave devices and replace by ZigBee. 

one never knows and with last device with Z-wave will be sell HC3 also.

 

my current ZigBee network is 20 devices vs 100 (now 65) works perfectly!

Here it's the other way around, 100 zwave - 30 zigbee (for now)

[xAPPO 18]

On 12/6/2020 at 3:09 PM, 10der said:

...now I understand what mirroring zigbee devices as QA is not a good idea cuz it’s eat memory. Too much.

so, I have remove all QA devices with zigbee and MQTT and create flows in NODE-RED

You are getting memory issues in MQTT QA’s too ?  I haven’t really seen this and I have around 100+ MQTT devices integrated with HC3 and some of those update frequently - every few seconds.  But just occasionally I do get stalls in processing.

[10der 832]

1 hour ago, xAPPO said:

You are getting memory issues in MQTT QA’s too ?  I haven’t really seen this and I have around 100+ MQTT devices integrated with HC3 and some of those update frequently - every few seconds.  But just occasionally I do get stalls in processing.

I am back to node-red. Hc3 still living with only zwave devices 

There is but one law in this mess render unto Caesar (bible)

[akatar 208]

 

 

 

On 1/26/2021 at 6:41 PM, 10der said:

unfortunately for example i am selling my Z-Wave devices and replace by ZigBee. 

one never knows and with last device with Z-wave will be sell HC3 also.

 

my current ZigBee network is 20 devices vs 100 (now 65) works perfectly!

The funny thing is that more and more people around me are doing the same.

 

Edited January 27, 2021 by akatar