All-in-One Scene: How to do it Better

[cag014 731]

4 minutes ago, SmartLifeSystems said:

I have got 2 QA with the AOQ and ~200 lines in the AOQ. The save for me is ~93 sec.

What !???

I have 10 QA and 150 lines, take less than 10 seconds...

Is it the save takes time? I mean when you press Save and popup menu on left appears "Changes saved".

You know let's do it differently, while AOQ starts there are messages like "Gathering information", Initializing and etc.

Could you post snapshot of that from debug window (Open full debug window) till data table appears.

[cag014 731]

4 hours ago, Rover said:

JS2n:

Please login or register to see this spoiler.

OK... Understood why it passed the checker... will fixed.

Please change your jS2n line, it's written incorrectly (why you're using back apostrophe in global names?

 XRandomLichten="`&XRaamGloriaLamp`|`&XLinksGobelin`|`&XBoekenkastRechts`|`&XAanrechtBijkeuken`|`&XKeukenlamp`",

change to (without back apostrophe)

 XRandomLichten="&XRaamGloriaLamp|&XLinksGobelin|&XBoekenkastRechts|&XAanrechtBijkeuken|&XKeukenlamp",

Edited September 14, 2020 by cag014

[cag014 731]

@Rover @SmartLifeSystems @gggizmo

As I understand it takes too long to start AOQ.

Could you please post you startup steps from debug window...

Like that

Please login or register to see this spoiler.

 

[Rover 47]

4 hours ago, cag014 said:

@Rover @SmartLifeSystems @gggizmo

As I understand it takes too long to start AOQ.

Could you please post you startup steps from debug window...

Like that

Please login or register to see this spoiler.

So 48 seconds.

• Quote

[SmartLifeSystems 20]

3 hours ago, Rover said:

Please login or register to see this spoiler.

So for me 117 sec.

Please login or register to see this image.

/monthly_2020_09/image.png.61158ebfe82a64881776723cc0d425a4.png" />

[cag014 731]

This is insane...

@SmartLifeSystems

looks like to execute same command using standard fibaro.call() function,  takes up to 20 seconds !! (see command setColor )

even to set global global variable in your system takes 4 seconds (while @Rover's system it takes 1 second.)

Please see turnOff bathroomLight - it takes 10 seconds.

Please see below setColor time execution (to remote HC2 and local HC3 rgb bulb) takes less than 1 second.

From some reason your system doesn't respond well, I believe that the delays that you have is from same reason.

Please login or register to see this spoiler.

 

 

 

Edited September 15, 2020 by cag014

[cag014 731]

16 hours ago, Rover said:

JM:

Please login or register to see this spoiler.

As I understand this is not a standard remote controller but emulation as kind of QuickApp.

That's way on block scene I saw weird values of centralScene.

could you post this QA or provide a link to jgab's download?

Is your real remote connected to the HC2? Because on next release you can use it as a device on HC3, no need any emulation or proxy.

 

Edited September 15, 2020 by cag014

[cag014 731]

7 hours ago, Rover said:

Please login or register to see this spoiler.

I extend my jM to 150 lines then it takes ~40 seconds (mostly because data validation and error checker).

This is very strange that you have 30 jM lines and it takes same time!!! But it depends on how complex your lines are.

 

Edited September 15, 2020 by cag014

[Rover 47]

5 hours ago, cag014 said:

As I understand this is not a standard remote controller but emulation as kind of QuickApp.

That's way on block scene I saw weird values of centralScene.

could you post this QA or provide a link to jgab's download?

Is your real remote connected to the HC2? Because on next release you can use it as a device on HC3, no need any emulation or proxy.

 

Yes all my remotes are still connected to HC2. I will migrate all devices to HC3 as soon as everything works in AOQ.

I hope your AOQ release with HC2 remotes capabilities will come soon. ?

Attached: jgab's HC2Proxy, in HC2 runs a HC3Proxy. Together they do the job.

Please login or register to see this attachment.

[Rover 47]

5 hours ago, cag014 said:

I extend my jM to 150 lines then it takes ~40 seconds (mostly because data validation and error checker).

This is very strange that you have 30 jM lines and it takes same time!!! But it depends on how complex your lines are.

 

I do not think my jM lines are on average complex.

There are many comment lines, do they cost validation time?

[Rover 47]

A line is triggered by remote or clock or global variable, etc.

Some lines I want to trigger (maybe also) via iPhone app. Then I need a scene to do the job.

What is the most efficient way to implement this in AOQ?

• Changing global variable in scene en then trigAct? Or otherwise?
• If a maybe long line is triggered by f.i. iClock and I want it also triggered by iPhone (method global), do I have to copy the line or can it be done more efficiently? Can iClock state and global variable state change be combined?

Edited September 15, 2020 by Rover

[SmartLifeSystems 20]

8 hours ago, cag014 said:

This is insane...

@SmartLifeSystems

looks like to execute same command using standard fibaro.call() function,  takes up to 20 seconds !! (see command setColor )

even to set global global variable in your system takes 4 seconds (while @Rover's system it takes 1 second.)

Please see turnOff bathroomLight - it takes 10 seconds.

Please see below setColor time execution (to remote HC2 and local HC3 rgb bulb) takes less than 1 second.

From some reason your system doesn't respond well, I believe that the delays that you have is from same reason.

Please login or register to see this spoiler.

 

Please login or register to see this image.

/monthly_2020_09/image.png.8dca09b6fb29b6b2286aa754fa5fafef.png" />

 

• Quote

[cag014 731]

3 hours ago, Rover said:

I do not think my jM lines are on average complex.

There are many comment lines, do they cost validation time?

No, comment lines are no seen by the code.

[gggizmo 6]

Please login or register to see this attachment.

 

62 sec. or i'm wrong?

[gggizmo 6]

Please login or register to see this attachment.

 

 

And again high cpu load and a lot of delay

 

Please login or register to see this attachment.

 

the only action triggered.

 

Good news: wall remotes are working perfectly...with some delay.1-2 sec

 

[cag014 731]

3 hours ago, Rover said:

A line is triggered by remote or clock or global variable, etc.

Some lines I want to trigger (maybe also) via iPhone app. Then I need a scene to do the job.

What is the most efficient way to implement this in AOQ?

• Changing global variable in scene en then trigAct? Or otherwise?
• If a maybe long line is triggered by f.i. iClock and I want it also triggered by iPhone (method global), do I have to copy the line or can it be done more efficiently? Can iClock state and global variable state change be combined?

The best way to do it is to create QuickApp device, for example as binary switch. (On/Off)

Now you have two options:

1. To change global variable which will trigger the AOQ

2. Actually to use this QuickApp device in jM to do whatever you need.

{0,"QAdev-ID",{state="value=true", trueAct={............}, falseAct={...........}}},

On your iPhone you will see QA device with a button to switch on/off.

 

I suggest to use second option. You can create specific room to include all necessary QA devices to trigger AOQ remotely.

 

 

[Rover 47]

6 hours ago, cag014 said:

The best way to do it is to create QuickApp device, for example as binary switch. (On/Off)

Now you have two options:

1. To change global variable which will trigger the AOQ

2. Actually to use this QuickApp device in jM to do whatever you need.

{0,"QAdev-ID",{state="value=true", trueAct={............}, falseAct={...........}}},

On your iPhone you will see QA device with a button to switch on/off.

 

I suggest to use second option. You can create specific room to include all necessary QA devices to trigger AOQ remotely.

 

 

Till now I only used the global variable way.

Indeed the second way is more versatile, only I am not experienced in building a QA.

But I have seen now that you can easily generate a QA-device in HC3 with a wizard.

Edited September 15, 2020 by Rover

[gggizmo 6]

Now no aoq 40block scenes active and same trigger in previous screenshot with aoq

Please login or register to see this attachment.

 

 

 

Please login or register to see this attachment.

 

 

 

I'm going insane...in hc2 aos reduced cpu and ram occupation and reduced avery kind of delay.

 

 

 

 

[SmartLifeSystems 20]

2 hours ago, gggizmo said:

Now no aoq 40block scenes active and same trigger in previous screenshot with aoq

Please login or register to see this attachment.

 

 

 

Please login or register to see this attachment.

 

 

 

I'm going insane...in hc2 aos reduced cpu and ram occupation and reduced avery kind of delay.

 

 

 

 

 

Yes, in my HC2 the RAM was 24% and no delay.

I don't understand, what did I do wrong. I have 2~6 sec delay.

[gggizmo 6]

2 minutes ago, SmartLifeSystems said:

 

Yes, in my HC2 the RAM was 24% and no delay.

I don't understand, what did I do wrong. I have 2~6 sec delay.

So, i'm not the only one. It was a pain but now everithing is working with block scenes, and i'm testing every new release of aoq hoping to find what's wrong in my system. I found the hc3 become slugghish every time you do a lot of things on web interface ( so you check diagnostic panel, history on another window, debug in another one and you are creating a block scene). Cpu load increases till 100% flat and stays flat if you close all browser windows too. I need to change ip address of hc3 and cpu load go down to normal.

So, there's something weird, but i don't know if is a defective unit. The only suggestion from fibaro support was to do a system repair, but that was the first thing i tried to solve...before reset to factory and total reconfiguration of every zwave device. So for now i'm glad to have just a working system...